In short

Classic polish air-dries and lasts 3 to 5 days. Semi-permanent (also called gel polish) is cured under an LED lamp: it gives colour for 3 to 4 weeks and is removed at the salon. Gel, or builder gel (BIAB overlay, extensions), strengthens the nail or adds length, and also lasts 3 to 4 weeks. A one-off event or a taste for changing colour: classic. Colour that lasts without a thought: semi-permanent. Nails that bend, break, or that you want longer: gel.

Almond nails in glossy burgundy polish, gold rings: a manicure at You Rêve Paris
On the day, a glossy polish looks much the same whichever formula is underneath: the difference shows in the days that follow.

What is the difference between classic polish, semi-permanent and gel?

All three go on the nail, but they do not use the same chemistry or do the same job. First, the definitions.

Classic polish, the “basic” manicure

Classic polish is a lacquer in solution: it dries in the air, by evaporation, and stays fragile for a while after application. It lasts 3 to 5 days on the hands, you can change it whenever you like, and you take it off at home with remover. It is the only one of the three that needs neither a lamp nor a salon visit for removal. At the salon it goes on a classic manicure (€40): the “basic” side of any basic-vs-gel manicure comparison.

What is a semi-permanent nail? Semi-permanent polish, or “gel polish”

Semi-permanent polish, also called gel polish and, by the name of one brand, Shellac (our guide to Shellac in Paris), is a resin-based polish. It is applied in thin coats, base, colour and top coat, and each coat is cured under an LED lamp. As it comes out from under the lamp, the nail is dry and glossy, for 3 to 4 weeks. At You Rêve it is the professional OPI GelColor range, close to 200 shades: an “OPI gel manicure” is exactly this. It is a layer of colour only: it neither lengthens nor builds the nail. The step-by-step application is in our semi-permanent guide.

Hands with short rounded nails in a very glossy deep blue polish, silver and gold rings
OPI gel polish on short nails: colour and shine are made to last 3 to 4 weeks.

What is gel? Builder gel, BIAB and extensions

When people talk about gel nails, they are no longer talking about polish. Builder gel is a thicker resin that is shaped, then cured under the lamp, to build something on the nail. At our salon it does two jobs:

In both cases the application is done at the salon, it takes longer than a polish, wear is 3 to 4 weeks, then comes an infill or a removal. Everything is on our BIAB overlay and extensions page; the nuance between BIAB and builder gel is in BIAB vs builder gel.

💡 “Gel polish” or “gel nails”: mind the words. Gel polish and semi-permanent name the same product: colour cured under a lamp (many salons also sell it as a “gel manicure”). Gel nails and builder gel are about building: strength or length. When a client tells us “I'd like gel”, our first question is: colour, strength or length?

Classic vs semi-permanent vs gel: the comparison table

CriterionClassic polishSemi-permanent (gel polish) OPIGel (BIAB overlay, extensions)
What it isA lacquer that air-driesA resin polish, cured under an LED lampA builder gel, cured under an LED lamp
DryingIn the air: coat after coat, and it stays fragile for a whileDry as it leaves the lamp, coat by coatDry as it leaves the lamp, coat by coat
Wear (hands)3 to 5 days3 to 4 weeks3 to 4 weeks, then infill or removal
What it givesColourColour and lasting shineStrength (BIAB) or length (extensions)
Nail lengthUnchangedUnchangedUnchanged with BIAB, longer with extensions
Effect on the nailNone: the nail is neither strengthened nor stressedA thin layer that dresses the nail without building itBIAB protects the nail while it grows; removal is more technical
RemovalAt home, with removerAt the salon (15 min), never peeled offAt the salon (20 min for an overlay), never peeled off
Price and time at the salonManicure + classic polish: €40, 40 minManicure + gel polish: €45, 45 min (application only: €30)BIAB overlay: from €60, 60-75 min; extensions from €65
Best forA one-off event, or changing colour oftenHealthy nails, and colour that lasts without a thoughtSoft, brittle or bitten nails (BIAB); wanting length (extensions)

To remember: on wear, there are two families, a few days for classic polish, 3 to 4 weeks for semi-permanent and gel. What sets those last two apart is therefore not how long they last, but what they do: give colour, or give structure.

Semi-permanent nail polish vs gel: what's the difference?

Same lamp, same layered application, but two jobs. Semi-permanent colours: it is a thin layer that dresses the nail as it is. Gel builds: it adds material, either to strengthen the nail without lengthening it (the BIAB overlay) or to extend it (extensions). The appointment is therefore longer (60-75 min for an overlay, against 45 min for a manicure with gel polish), so is the removal (20 min against 15 min), and the price is higher.

Does gel last longer than semi-permanent?

At You Rêve the stated wear is the same: 3 to 4 weeks. The difference is strength. On a soft or brittle nail, gel polish goes with the nail when it bends, whereas the overlay protects the nail itself while it grows. The much longer lifespans you sometimes read for gel come from upkeep: an infill around the third week, then a fresh set every two to three months. Gel polish, for its part, is removed and reapplied at every appointment.

Mainly torn between gel polish and a BIAB overlay? Our comparison gel polish or BIAB puts them side by side: wear, price, removal and nail type.

Pros and cons of classic polish, semi-permanent and gel

Classic polish: pros and cons

Pros:

Cons:

Semi-permanent (gel polish): pros and cons

Pros:

Cons:

Gel (BIAB overlay, extensions): pros and cons

Pros:

Cons:

Almond nails with a gel overlay and nail art: burgundy bows on nude, stripes, dots and gold stars
A gel overlay with nail art: strength can be worn with decoration too.

What is the healthiest nail option?

None of the three harms the nail by itself. What harms it is peeling and a removal done in a hurry, on gel as on gel polish. In order of what each asks of the nail:

Are your nails already damaged, soft, splitting, ridged after a removal done at home? The BIAB overlay is the application that protects them while they grow, and our article damaged nails after gel polish or gel goes through the right steps. A nail that changes colour, hurts or lifts from the nail bed is a matter for a doctor (or a podiatrist, for the feet), not for a manicure: we are beauty therapists, not doctors.

Nail polish price comparison: what each option costs in Paris

Salon prices, read from our live menu. On the manicure side, moving from classic polish to gel polish costs €5 more, for 3 to 4 weeks of wear instead of 3 to 5 days. Gel is a different category: you are no longer paying for a colour, but for a longer application that strengthens or lengthens the nail.

ServicePriceTimeOff-peak price
Classic manicure + classic polish€4040 min€35
Classic manicure + OPI gel polish€4545 min€40
Gel polish application only (hands)€3030 min€30
BIAB overlay, colour built in€6060 min€55
BIAB overlay + gel polish€7075 min€65
Extensions with tips (from)€6575 min—

The off-peak price is a reduced price on quiet weekday slots, subject to availability; it appears when you book.

And removal? If you arrive with an existing set, it is added: €10 for gel polish (€5 if a new gel polish follows), €20 for an overlay (€10 if a new overlay follows, in the same booking). The reduced price applies when the new application is of the same type (gel polish before gel polish, overlay before overlay): removing gel polish stays at €10 before an overlay.

How to choose: classic polish, semi-permanent or gel?

💡 Not sure about the shade? Our colour recommendation tool suggests the OPI shades that suit your skin tone, whichever formula you pick, classic or gel polish. You arrive at the salon with 3 references ready to compare.

Removal and aftercare: making each one last

The rule holds for everything that cures under a lamp: do not peel it off, even if a corner lifts. Wait for the removal at the salon.

Manicure tables at You Rêve Paris: white LED lamps, cream chairs and shelves of OPI polish
The manicure tables at 7 rue d'Argenteuil: gel polish and BIAB are applied here, under the same LED lamp.

Visiting Paris? The three at the salon

Still hesitating? Book, and we'll talk it through before we start

Classic, gel polish or gel: we choose together, according to your nails, your routine and your next occasion. Manicure + gel polish €45 (45 min), BIAB overlay from €60 (60 min).

Book my manicure

Frequently asked questions

Classic polish air-dries, gives colour and lasts 3 to 5 days. Semi-permanent is a resin polish cured under an LED lamp: the same job, but 3 to 4 weeks of wear and a removal at the salon (15 min). Gel is a thicker builder gel: it strengthens the nail (BIAB overlay) or lengthens it (extensions), also for 3 to 4 weeks, with an infill or a removal at the salon (20 min for an overlay).

A semi-permanent nail is a nail wearing a resin polish cured under an LED lamp, which lasts 3 to 4 weeks. It is the same thing as gel polish, and Shellac is one brand of it, as OPI GelColor is the range we use. “Gel nails” are something else: builder gel, used to strengthen or lengthen the nail.

At You Rêve, both are made to last 3 to 4 weeks on the hands: gel polish, BIAB overlay, extensions and builder gel alike. On the toes, gel polish also lasts 3 to 4 weeks. Gel can look as if it lasts longer because it is maintained: an infill around the third week, then a fresh set every two to three months. Classic polish lasts 3 to 5 days.

None of the three harms the nail by itself: what harms it is peeling and a removal done in a hurry. Classic polish is the lightest, since it comes off with remover, but it protects nothing. Gel polish or gel, applied and removed at the salon by gentle buffing of the surface and a controlled soak, does not weaken the nail in the long run, and a BIAB overlay is designed to protect a fragile nail while it grows. Never pick off a set yourself.

“Fake nails” covers several techniques (press-ons, acrylic, tips, Gel-X, sculpted gel), and none is healthier than gel by nature: what matters is the application and, above all, the removal. Forcing off any set takes the top layers of the nail with it. Our BIAB overlay adds no length, extensions add it on purpose. If your nails are already weak, tell us when you book and we will advise.

Semi-permanent: a removal at the salon (€10, 15 min, or €5 if a new gel polish follows), a return visit every 3 to 4 weeks, and a thin layer that does not strengthen a soft nail. Gel: a longer and dearer appointment (60-75 min for an overlay, from €60), a more technical removal (20 min) and regular upkeep, with an infill (€60) around the third week. For both, never peel them off yourself. Some people's skin reacts to the resin: if you get redness or itching, stop and ask a doctor.

For a fixed date, gel polish applied a few days before is the calmest option: colour and shine are made to last 3 to 4 weeks, well beyond the day itself. Classic polish works if you apply it the day before or the morning of, knowing that it lasts 3 to 5 days. If your nails tend to break before a big day, mention the BIAB overlay when you book.

Classic manicure + classic polish: €40 (40 min). Classic manicure + OPI gel polish: €45 (45 min); gel polish application only: €30 (30 min). BIAB overlay with colour built in: €60 (60 min); BIAB overlay + gel polish: €70 (75 min); extensions from €65. Removal: €10 for gel polish (€5 if a new gel polish follows), €20 for an overlay (€10 if a new overlay follows, in the same booking).

We advise against it: they do not come off like classic polish, and peeling takes the top layers of the nail with it. Only classic polish is removed at home, with remover. For gel polish and gel, removal is done at the salon.

Further reading